Content Warning: discussion of sexual assault in media.
I started reading The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen graphic novel after watching the movie. I’m only twenty or thirty pages in, and there have been two instances of sexual assault. I pause and reflect on other stories I have read written by Alan Moore. There’s another instance of attempted sexual assault in Watchmen. It made me wonder why Alan Moore utilizes rape with his female characters in his stories. It’s not something I alone have been wondering about. Typing into google “Why does Alan Moore write about rape” and there are countless articles as to why he writes about rape regularly. I wanted to discuss my thoughts about this because, as a reader, I’m tired of putting sexual assault as back story for women in media.
Before exploring this topic, there are a couple of things I want to address. I’m not saying sexual violence or rape shouldn’t be written about nor that if it’s included it’s automatically misogynist. There are ways to address sexual violence in a way that’s respectful to survivors. Most often, I see sexual assault being used as a plot device to demean the characters, and it doesn’t contribute to their development. The last statement I want to make is that anyone of any gender can be victims of assault. I cite female characters in this post as I see female characters being subjected to sexual assault in Moore’s work. However, anyone can be a victim of assault.
If we look at Alan Moore’s statements in this article, where he addresses sexual violence against women in his stories, he states, “As regards non-sexual violence, there is clearly a lot more non-sexual violence in my work that there is violence of the sexual variety, although in our current culture that’s true of nearly everyone’s work, isn’t it?” His instances of consensual sexual activity don’t undo the scenes he writes. Further into the article, Moore talks about the implications of rape, throwing out statistics of sexual assault. It seems Moore is educated about the origins of sexual assault and why it happens.
In the first paragraph, I mention how I’m tired of seeing sexual assault being used as a plot device to make a female character strong while also showing how evil a character can be. Rape doesn’t always have to be utilized to demonstrate this in media. Manipulation or gaslighting are alternative options to inform the viewer how evil a character can be.
I remember the first time I read The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo. I was in high school, and I had no idea what I would be reading. Lisbeth is subjected to many forms of abuse. However, there’s so much more to her strength than only surviving her rapes. She’s a hacker, has a photographic memory, and can intelligently plot her way out of a horrific situation. Plus, Lisbeth gets back at her rapist, physically scarring him. I have never read a book where a rape victim got savage revenge against her rapist. It doesn’t undo the scene itself, but it makes it more manageable to read about.
I still enjoy reading Alan Moore’s work. Moore wrote these stories to be enjoyed by readers, so it shouldn’t be a surprise when readers connect the dots between the way he tells his stories. If anyone finds sexual assault triggering in any way, I highly recommend never reading anything by Alan Moore. I’d be happy to hear in the comments section below on your thoughts with SA in fiction, along with your opinions on Alan Moore’s stories.























